Johnny Tincher — Common 54 OVR Catcher Overview
Johnny Tincher is a Common 54 OVR Catcher card for the Free Agents, part of the Live set in MLB The Show's Diamond Dynasty. He bats right-handed. The card was added to Diamond Dynasty in April 2026.
Johnny Tincher grades out at 66 Arm Strength, 60 Fielding, and 54 Speed.
Johnny Tincher is eligible at 2 positions, and DiamondOps scores each one separately: Catcher (51.2) and Designated Hitter (31.3) on All-Star. The card is strongest at its listed position, Catcher, at every difficulty. At Catcher the card scores 51.2 on All-Star, 52.6 on Hall of Fame, and 52.7 on Legend — it keeps 103% of its All-Star value at the top difficulty, which is unusually durable. Among Catchers the card ranks #195 on Hall of Fame and #204 on All-Star.
On the Diamond Dynasty market, Johnny Tincher currently buys for about 7 stubs, with sell orders near 0 stubs. Over the past 7 days the price has held roughly steady. Its quick-sell value of 5 stubs sits at or above the sell price, making it quick-sell viable. DiamondOps suggests waiting for a better entry point.
OpScore is DiamondOps' composite rating of a card's in-game performance value. Johnny Tincher earns an OpScore of 52.7 on Legend difficulty, ranking #2516 among all cards and #197 among Catchers.
Common questions
- What is Johnny Tincher's overall rating in MLB The Show 26?
- Johnny Tincher is a 54 OVR Common Catcher for the Free Agents.
- Is Johnny Tincher a good card in MLB The Show 26?
- Among Catchers, Johnny Tincher ranks #204 on All-Star, #195 on Hall of Fame, and #197 on Legend by OpScore — DiamondOps' difficulty-aware rating: it weights the attributes that decide at-bats and recomputes them for each difficulty, whereas in-game Overall is a single number that does not change with the level you play on.
- How much does Johnny Tincher cost in Diamond Dynasty?
- The last recorded buy-now price was 7 stubs. Prices move constantly on the in-game marketplace — the chart on this page tracks the card's real history rather than a single snapshot.
Where to go next
Every link below comes from this card's own series, team, rarity, position, or the collections and programs it belongs to.
- Starter — Collect Common PlayersA collection this card counts toward.
- Starter — Collect InfieldersA collection this card counts toward.
- Best CatchersThe top catchers in the game, ranked by OpScore.
- Live CardsEvery Live card, filterable by position, team and rating.
- Free Agents CardsEvery Free Agents card in the game, with live market prices.
- Common CardsEvery Common card, ranked by overall rating.
- Live Series CardsLive Series prices move on real-world performance, so they are the only cards where following actual MLB box scores is a trading edge.
- Live Series CommonsWhen a Common costs meaningfully more than its quick-sell price, a collection or mission is driving it — the card itself is not the reason.
- Diamond RadarWhich cards our model predicts will be upgraded at the next roster update.