James McArthur
Price History
Where to get it
- Community Market
- Daily login reward
- Packs
The source types MLB The Show lists for this card. A pack or program may no longer be available.
James McArthur — Common 64 OVR Closer Overview
James McArthur is a Common 64 OVR Closer card for the Free Agents, part of the Live set in MLB The Show's Diamond Dynasty. He throws right-handed. The card was added to Diamond Dynasty in April 2026.
On the mound, James McArthur works with a 4-pitch arsenal led by a 95 mph Sinker and a 95 mph 4-Seam Fastball. His pitching ratings include 99 Velocity, 61 Control, and 99 Break. The profile favors a movement-heavy arsenal built to miss bats.
DiamondOps grades each pitch in James McArthur's arsenal: Slider (S), Sinker (S), 4-Seam Fastball (S), and Slurve (B). 3 of them grade S-tier, which is what separates a genuine out-pitch mix from a deep-but-flat arsenal. Its strongest tunnel pairing is the Sinker off the 4-Seam Fastball, so the two share a release look. Its 99 mph Sinker adds a velocity bonus on top. Arsenal grades are the same at every difficulty — unlike a hitter's OpScore, a pitch mix does not re-weight as you climb.
On the Diamond Dynasty market, James McArthur currently buys for about 6 stubs, with sell orders near 0 stubs. Over the past 7 days the buy price has fallen roughly 14%. Its quick-sell value of 5 stubs sits at or above the sell price, making it quick-sell viable. DiamondOps currently rates the card a buy at this price.
OpScore is DiamondOps' composite rating of a card's in-game performance value. James McArthur earns an OpScore of 59.8 on Legend difficulty, ranking #2342 among all cards and #111 among Closers.
Live Series cards like James McArthur's are the ones Diamond Radar scores: it reads a player's real MLB production and predicts what the next roster update will do to the card — the predicted rating, the tier jump, and how likely the upgrade is. Ratings only move at a roster update, and not every Live Series card is scored in a given window. Model v11: of the 358 cards it scored 70 or above in its 3 graded updates, 69% were upgraded, against 17% by chance: 4.1× better.
Common questions
- What is James McArthur's overall rating in MLB The Show 26?
- James McArthur is a 64 OVR Common Closer for the Free Agents.
- Is James McArthur a good card in MLB The Show 26?
- Among Closers, James McArthur ranks #107 on All-Star, #111 on Hall of Fame, and #111 on Legend by OpScore — DiamondOps' difficulty-aware rating: it weights the attributes that decide at-bats and recomputes them for each difficulty, whereas in-game Overall is a single number that does not change with the level you play on.
- How much does James McArthur cost in Diamond Dynasty?
- The last recorded buy-now price was 6 stubs. Prices move constantly on the in-game marketplace — the chart on this page tracks the card's real history rather than a single snapshot.
- How do I get James McArthur in MLB The Show 26?
- MLB The Show lists 3 sources for this card: Community Market, Daily login reward, and Packs. A pack or program may no longer be available.
Where to go next
Every link below comes from this card's own series, team, rarity, position, or the collections and programs it belongs to.
- Starter — Collect Common PlayersA collection this card counts toward.
- Best Closing PitchersThe top closing pitchers in the game, ranked by OpScore.
- Live CardsEvery Live card, filterable by position, team and rating.
- Free Agents CardsEvery Free Agents card in the game, with live market prices.
- Common CardsEvery Common card, ranked by overall rating.
- Live Series CardsLive Series prices move on real-world performance, so they are the only cards where following actual MLB box scores is a trading edge.
- Live Series CommonsWhen a Common costs meaningfully more than its quick-sell price, a collection or mission is driving it — the card itself is not the reason.
- Diamond RadarWhich cards our model predicts will be upgraded at the next roster update.