Payton Tolle is a Silver 78 OVR Starting Pitcher card for the Red Sox, part of the Live set in MLB The Show's Diamond Dynasty. He throws left-handed. The card was added to Diamond Dynasty in April 2026.

On the mound, Payton Tolle works with a 5-pitch arsenal led by a 97 mph 4-Seam Fastball and a 90 mph Cutter. His pitching ratings include 87 Velocity, 52 Control, and 69 Break. The profile favors a movement-heavy arsenal built to miss bats.

DiamondOps grades each pitch in Payton Tolle's arsenal: Slider (S), 4-Seam Fastball (S), Cutter (S), Circle Change (A), and Curveball (B). 3 of them grade S-tier, which is what separates a genuine out-pitch mix from a deep-but-flat arsenal. Its strongest tunnel pairing is the Cutter off the Slider, so the two share a release look. Velocity works against the card here — its 87 mph 4-Seam Fastball is slow enough to cost it in the arsenal score. Arsenal grades are the same at every difficulty — unlike a hitter's OpScore, a pitch mix does not re-weight as you climb.

On the Diamond Dynasty market, Payton Tolle currently buys for about 171 stubs, with sell orders near 126 stubs. Over the past 7 days the buy price has fallen roughly 60%. Flipping at current buy and sell prices nets roughly 26 stubs, about a 20% return. DiamondOps currently rates the card a buy at this price.

OpScore is DiamondOps' composite rating of a card's in-game performance value. Payton Tolle earns an OpScore of 58.2 on Legend difficulty, ranking #2010 among all cards and #433 among Starting Pitchers.