DiamondOps

Best Starting Pitchers

Ranked by OpScore at Hall of Fame difficulty · updating

OpScore: Hall of Fame algorithm
Filters1 active
RankHoFⓘPOSPos rankHoFⓘArsenalⓘP / H Splitⓘ
18
Shohei Ohtani
Shohei Ohtani2-Way

2026 Finest

SP+1
Red Diamond99116.41—
P 108.1H 116.4
22
Cool Papa Bell
Cool Papa Bell2-Way

The Negro Leagues

SP+4
Red Diamond99115.72—
P 93.9H 115.7
61
Cam Schlittler
Cam Schlittler

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99111.93——
90
Nolan Ryan
Nolan Ryan

Milestone

SP
Red Diamond99110.44——
90
Nolan Ryan
Nolan Ryan

Milestone

SP
Red Diamond99110.44——
121
Randy Johnson
Randy Johnson

Spooky

SP
Red Diamond99109.06——
121
Randy Johnson
Randy Johnson

Spooky

SP
Red Diamond99109.06——
127
Bob Gibson
Bob Gibson

Awards

SP
Red Diamond99108.78——
166
Gavin Williams
Gavin Williams

2026 Postseason

SP
Red Diamond99107.29——
174
Justin Verlander
Justin Verlander

Awards

SP
Red Diamond99106.910——
187
J.R. Richard
J.R. Richard

Spooky

SP
Red Diamond99106.611——
187
J.R. Richard
J.R. Richard

Spooky

SP
Red Diamond99106.611——
208
Chris Sale
Chris Sale

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99105.913——
213
Jacob deGrom
Jacob deGrom

Spotlight

SP
Red Diamond99105.614——
215
Pedro Martinez
Pedro Martinez

Milestone

SP
Red Diamond99105.515——
231
Yoshinobu Yamamoto
Yoshinobu Yamamoto

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99105.016——
236
Cam Schlittler
Cam Schlittler

2026 All-Star

SP
Red Diamond98104.817——
241
Sean Burke
Sean Burke

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99104.618——
245
Garrett Crochet
Garrett Crochet

Milestone

SP
Red Diamond99104.519——
259
Felix Hernandez
Felix Hernandez

Awards

SP
Red Diamond99104.220——
263
Shane Baz
Shane Baz

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99104.021——
266
Tarik Skubal
Tarik Skubal

New Threads

SP
Red Diamond99103.922——
266
Cade Cavalli
Cade Cavalli

Spotlight

SP
Red Diamond99103.922——
271
Jacob Misiorowski
Jacob Misiorowski

2026 Postseason

SP
Red Diamond99103.824——
282
Gavin Williams
Gavin Williams

Spotlight

SP
Red Diamond99103.525——
282
Freddy Peralta
Freddy Peralta

2026 Postseason

SP
Red Diamond99103.525——
300
John Donaldson
John Donaldson2-Way

The Negro Leagues

SP+4
Red Diamond99103.127—
P 103.1H 78.2
300
Cristopher Sánchez
Cristopher Sánchez

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99103.127——
307
Sandy Alcantara
Sandy Alcantara

Milestone

SP
Red Diamond97102.929——
311
Seth Hernandez
Seth Hernandez

Pipeline

SP
Red Diamond99102.830——
327
Smokey Joe Williams
Smokey Joe Williams2-Way

The Negro Leagues

SP+3
Red Diamond99102.331—
P 95.4H 102.3
333
Drew Rasmussen
Drew Rasmussen

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99102.032——
334
Nolan McLean
Nolan McLean

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99101.933——
334
Dylan Cease
Dylan Cease

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99101.933——
346
Tarik Skubal
Tarik Skubal

Summer

SP
Red Diamond98101.635——
353
Paul Skenes
Paul Skenes

2026 Topps Update Series Baseball

SP
Red Diamond99101.336——
357
Troy Melton
Troy Melton

Spotlight

SP
Red Diamond97101.237——
367
Jackson Flora
Jackson Flora

2026 Draft

SP
Red Diamond98101.038——
367
Zack Wheeler
Zack Wheeler

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99101.038——
378
Dustin May
Dustin May

New Threads

SP
Red Diamond99100.740——
391
Kerry Wood
Kerry Wood

Spooky

SP
Red Diamond99100.341——
391
Kerry Wood
Kerry Wood

Spooky

SP
Red Diamond99100.341——
391
Payton Tolle
Payton Tolle

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99100.341——
391
Jesús Luzardo
Jesús Luzardo

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99100.341——
400
Walbert Ureña
Walbert Ureña

2026 Finest

SP
Red Diamond99100.245——
407
Chase Burns
Chase Burns

2026 Topps Update Series Baseball

SP
Red Diamond99100.046——
419
Anibal Sanchez
Anibal Sanchez

Milestone

SP
Red Diamond9999.847——
419
Anibal Sanchez
Anibal Sanchez

Ranked 1000

SP
Red Diamond9999.847——
426
Ryan Sloan
Ryan Sloan

Pipeline

SP
Red Diamond9999.749——
426
Bryan Woo
Bryan Woo

Spotlight

SP
Red Diamond9999.749——
Showing 1–50 of 50 cards

How the starting pitchers ranking is built

This list ranks starting pitchers by OpScore, not by in-game Overall. Overall is a single number that never changes with the difficulty you play on; OpScore re-weights what actually wins games and recomputes it per difficulty, so the best card on All-Star is often not the best on Legend.

For starting pitchers the weighting leans on arsenal quality — arsenal quality over velocity — the out-pitch and the third offering decide games, not the radar gun. That is why a card with a lower Overall and one genuinely unhittable pitch can outrank a balanced arm the market prices far higher.

Cards eligible at starting pitcher through a secondary position are included, because when you are filling this slot the best available option is often a card listed elsewhere. Every row links to that card’s full page — live price, OpScore breakdown, quirks, and price history.

Other positions: Catchers · First Basemen · Second Basemen · Third Basemen · Shortstops · Left Fielders · Center Fielders · Right Fielders · Designated Hitters · Relief Pitchers · Closing Pitchers

OpScore & rankings guide