DiamondOps

Best Shortstops

Ranked by OpScore at Hall of Fame difficulty · updating

OpScore: Hall of Fame algorithm
Filters1 active
RankHoFⓘPOSOpScoreHoFⓘAt SSⓘPos rankHoFⓘArsenalⓘP / H Splitⓘ
14
Elly De La Cruz
Elly De La Cruz

2026 Finest

SS
Red Diamond99116.9
116.9
1——
39
Ceddanne Rafaela
Ceddanne Rafaela

2026 Finest

CF+2
Red Diamond99113.8
115.02nd
1——
25
Honus Wagner
Honus Wagner

2026 Topps Update Series Baseball

SS+6
Red Diamond99114.8
114.8
2——
10
Ben Zobrist
Ben Zobrist

MLBx

2B+6
Red Diamond99117.8
114.62nd
1——
31
Ozzie Smith
Ozzie Smith

Awards

SS
Red Diamond99114.4
114.4
3——
38
Bobby Witt Jr.
Bobby Witt Jr.

2026 Topps Update Series Baseball

SS
Red Diamond99114.0
114.0
4——
51
Otto Lopez
Otto Lopez

2026 Finest

SS+1
Red Diamond99112.8
112.8
5——
55
Jimmy Rollins
Jimmy Rollins

Prime

SS
Red Diamond99112.5
112.5
6——
61
Willie Wells
Willie Wells

The Negro Leagues

SS+3
Red Diamond99111.9
111.9
7——
66
Tony Fernandez
Tony Fernandez

Awards

SS
Red Diamond99111.5
111.5
8——
85
Cooper Pratt
Cooper Pratt

2026 Postseason

SS+1
Red Diamond99110.5
110.5
9——
105
Mickey Mantle
Mickey Mantle

Moonshot

CF+6
Red Diamond99109.6
110.52nd
10——
85
Konnor Griffin
Konnor Griffin

2026 Topps Update Series Baseball

SS+2
Red Diamond99110.5
110.5
9——
46
Jorge Polanco
Jorge Polanco

Spooky

2B+1
Red Diamond99113.4
109.92nd
6——
46
Jorge Polanco
Jorge Polanco

Spooky

2B+1
Red Diamond99113.4
109.92nd
6——
114
Jesús Made
Jesús Made

Pipeline

SS+2
Red Diamond99109.2
109.2
11——
39
Chone Figgins
Chone Figgins

Moonshot

3B+5
Red Diamond99113.8
109.12nd
2——
132
Pop Lloyd
Pop Lloyd

The Negro Leagues

SS+2
Red Diamond99108.5
108.5
12——
144
Troy Tulowitzki
Troy Tulowitzki

Milestone

SS
Red Diamond99108.0
108.0
13——
150
Lou Boudreau
Lou Boudreau

Awards

SS
Red Diamond99107.9
107.9
14——
150
Lou Boudreau
Lou Boudreau

Ranked 1000

SS
Red Diamond99107.9
107.9
14——
85
Nico Hoerner
Nico Hoerner

2026 Postseason

2B+1
Red Diamond99110.5
107.82nd
11——
162
Cole Carrigg
Cole Carrigg

Spotlight

CF+5
Red Diamond99107.4
107.82nd
18——
154
Francisco Lindor
Francisco Lindor

Milestone

SS
Red Diamond99107.7
107.7
16——
158
Phil Rizzuto
Phil Rizzuto

Awards

SS
Red Diamond99107.6
107.6
17——
114
Willard Brown
Willard Brown

The Negro Leagues

LF+4
Red Diamond99109.2
107.52nd
6——
75
David Hamilton
David Hamilton

2026 Postseason

3B+2
Red Diamond99110.9
107.32nd
5——
167
Kevin McGonigle
Kevin McGonigle

2026 Topps Update Series Baseball

SS+3
Red Diamond99107.1
107.1
18——
150
Honus Wagner
Honus Wagner

Milestone

CF+4
Red Diamond99107.9
107.02nd
17——
103
Nick Sogard
Nick Sogard

Spotlight

2B+5
Red Diamond99109.9
106.82nd
13——
187
Leo De Vries
Leo De Vries

Pipeline

SS+2
Red Diamond99106.6
106.6
19——
210
Oneil Cruz
Oneil Cruz

2026 Finest

CF+1
Red Diamond99105.8
106.62nd
22——
196
Derek Jeter
Derek Jeter

Subway

SS
Red Diamond99106.2
106.2
20——
204
Eli Willits
Eli Willits

Pipeline

SS+2
Red Diamond99106.1
106.1
21——
204
Ezequiel Duran
Ezequiel Duran

Spotlight

SS+6
Red Diamond99106.1
106.1
21——
158
JJ Wetherholt
JJ Wetherholt

2026 Topps Update Series Baseball

2B+2
Red Diamond99107.6
105.42nd
18——
221
CJ Abrams
CJ Abrams

2026 Finest

SS+1
Red Diamond99105.3
105.3
23——
154
Red Schoendienst
Red Schoendienst

Signature

2B+3
Red Diamond98107.7
105.22nd
17——
226
Josuar Gonzalez
Josuar Gonzalez

Pipeline

SS+1
Red Diamond99105.1
105.1
24——
137
Kris Bryant
Kris Bryant

Spotlight

3B+5
Red Diamond99108.3
104.72nd
11——
256
Jeremy Peña
Jeremy Peña

2026 Postseason

SS
Red Diamond99104.3
104.3
25——
204
Nasim Nuñez
Nasim Nuñez

Spotlight

2B+1
Red Diamond96106.1
104.22nd
26——
266
Ceddanne Rafaela
Ceddanne Rafaela

2026 All-Star

CF+2
Red Diamond98103.9
104.12nd
28——
260
Zach Neto
Zach Neto

2026 Finest

SS
Red Diamond99104.1
104.1
26——
167
Chase Meidroth
Chase Meidroth

2026 Postseason

2B+2
Red Diamond99107.1
103.92nd
19——
266
Bobby Witt Jr.
Bobby Witt Jr.

2026 All-Star

SS
Red Diamond98103.9
103.9
27——
271
Michael Young
Michael Young

Cornerstone

SS+3
Red Diamond99103.8
103.8
28——
279
Barry Larkin
Barry Larkin

Field of Dreams

SS
Red Diamond99103.6
103.6
29——
69
Julio Franco
Julio Franco

MLBx

1B+2
Red Diamond99111.4
103.62nd
18——
196
Ernie Clement
Ernie Clement

Cover Athletes

2B+3
Red Diamond99106.2
103.42nd
24——
Showing 1–50 of 50 cards

How the shortstops ranking is built

This list ranks shortstops by OpScore, not by in-game Overall. Overall is a single number that never changes with the difficulty you play on; OpScore re-weights what actually wins games and recomputes it per difficulty, so the best card on All-Star is often not the best on Legend.

For shortstops the weighting leans on the deepest infield pool in the game, and the position where OpScore most often disagrees with price. Where that disagrees with the market — and it frequently does, because the market pays for the headline Overall — the gap is the value.

Cards eligible at shortstop through a secondary position are included, because when you are filling this slot the best available option is often a card listed elsewhere. Every row links to that card’s full page — live price, OpScore breakdown, quirks, and price history.

Other positions: Catchers · First Basemen · Second Basemen · Third Basemen · Left Fielders · Center Fielders · Right Fielders · Designated Hitters · Starting Pitchers · Relief Pitchers · Closing Pitchers

OpScore & rankings guide