Payton Tolle
Price History
Where to get it
- Community Market
The source types MLB The Show lists for this card. A pack or program may no longer be available.
Payton Tolle — Diamond 94 OVR Starting Pitcher Overview
Payton Tolle is a Diamond 94 OVR Starting Pitcher card for the Red Sox, part of the Mural set in MLB The Show's Diamond Dynasty. He throws left-handed. The card was added to Diamond Dynasty in June 2026.
On the mound, Payton Tolle works with a 5-pitch arsenal led by a 96 mph 4-Seam Fastball and a 95 mph Sinker. His pitching ratings include 99 Velocity, 91 Control, and 95 Break. The profile favors a balanced mix of command and movement. Notable quirks include Break Outlier from a total of 3 quirks.
DiamondOps grades each pitch in Payton Tolle's arsenal: 4-Seam Fastball (S), Sinker (S), Cutter (S), Circle Change (A), and Slurve (B). 3 of them grade S-tier, which is what separates a genuine out-pitch mix from a deep-but-flat arsenal. Its strongest tunnel pairing is the 4-Seam Fastball off the Sinker, so the two share a release look. Its 99 mph Sinker adds a velocity bonus on top. Arsenal grades are the same at every difficulty — unlike a hitter's OpScore, a pitch mix does not re-weight as you climb.
On the Diamond Dynasty market, Payton Tolle currently buys for about 18,500 stubs, with sell orders near 10,051 stubs. Over the past 7 days the buy price has climbed roughly 43%. Flipping at current buy and sell prices nets roughly 6,597 stubs, about a 66% return. DiamondOps flags the card as currently overpriced.
OpScore is DiamondOps' composite rating of a card's in-game performance value. Payton Tolle earns an OpScore of 89.9 on Legend difficulty, ranking #905 among all cards and #167 among Starting Pitchers.
Common questions
- What is Payton Tolle's overall rating in MLB The Show 26?
- Payton Tolle is a 94 OVR Diamond Starting Pitcher for the Red Sox.
- Is Payton Tolle a good card in MLB The Show 26?
- Among Starting Pitchers, Payton Tolle ranks #145 on All-Star, #165 on Hall of Fame, and #167 on Legend by OpScore — DiamondOps' difficulty-aware rating: it weights the attributes that decide at-bats and recomputes them for each difficulty, whereas in-game Overall is a single number that does not change with the level you play on.
- What quirks does Payton Tolle have in MLB The Show 26?
- Payton Tolle has 3 quirks: Homebody, Night Player, and Break Outlier.
- How much does Payton Tolle cost in Diamond Dynasty?
- The last recorded buy-now price was 18,500 stubs. Prices move constantly on the in-game marketplace — the chart on this page tracks the card's real history rather than a single snapshot.
- How do I get Payton Tolle in MLB The Show 26?
- MLB The Show lists one source for this card: Community Market. A pack or program may no longer be available.
Where to go next
Every link below comes from this card's own series, team, rarity, position, or the collections and programs it belongs to.
- Legends and Flashbacks — MuralA collection this card counts toward.
- Best Starting PitchersThe top starting pitchers in the game, ranked by OpScore.
- Mural CardsEvery Mural card, filterable by position, team and rating.
- Red Sox CardsEvery Red Sox card in the game, with live market prices.
- Diamond CardsEvery Diamond card, ranked by overall rating.
- High Diamonds (85+ OVR)Overall is one number that never changes with difficulty. Two 87s can be a full tier apart in practice, which is what OpScore on each row is for.
- Diamond RadarWhich cards our model predicts will be upgraded at the next roster update.